Nonprofits: The Evolution to the Business Model

By John Burnett, SDSVP Partner

There’s a rumor going around that nonprofits are in big trouble. Recent numbers seem to bear this out. For instance, according to Giving USA, the total estimated charitable giving in the U.S. dropped 3.6 percent in 2009. The Center for Wealth and Philanthropy at Boston College said in its report that individual giving fell 4.6 percent in 2009 but for the rest of 2010 will likely grow to up to $227 billion. This sounds good until you realize that U.S. nonprofits need $1 trillion to operate fully.

There is also the other side of the coin. The needs for the services provided by nonprofits have increased by 30-40 percent during the period since 2008. This trend will continue as more individuals lose their unemployment benefits and suffer greater problems.

The response from nonprofits has been predictable. When-in-doubt cut costs – limit travel, count paper clips, reduce benefits; and, most painfully, cut staff, cut salaries/time, and eliminate programs. All these cuts threaten the Mission of the organization and the reason for its being. The assumption made by many Executive Directors is to wait, and things will turn around- they always have before.

Of course, there is always the possibility that the nonprofit can take action. Learning about social media is the current hot button; hiring a fundraiser, who, in turn, puts in place an elaborate program that includes finding 2-3 angel givers; recreating the Board so that it gets and gives; and organizing a new gala, are all potential components. Even a bit of token Marketing is possible. “All these changes will allow us to operate a couple more years, and then the economy will be better.”

Based on my twenty years working with nonprofits in a number of capacities, I have concluded that these band-aids are not the solutions needed. It is not the bad economy, or the donor who quit giving; it is a fundamental flaw in the nonprofit model. Organizations cannot endure if their fundamental goal is to breakeven every year or they are not allowed to delete programs/services that don’t make sense. The world has changed and nonprofits must adapt to a business model that is relevant, implementable and realistic. The process of creating such a model is well established. It starts with a review of your situation including the mission, a SWOT, objectives, strategies, tactics, budgeting, and evaluation. However, the challenge is the lack of resources necessary to create this document and implement it fully.

One possible solution for this lack of resources is for the nonprofit to connect with an organization that can guide them through this process and keep them on track. Although there are many possibilities, San Diego Social Venture Partners is one that I have recently joined and feel offers all the elements to help nonprofits succeed and sustain. Check them out at http://www.sdsvp.org/.


Click here to read more about John Burnett.

Philanthropy and the Economy – Part III

SDSVP is continuing to compile articles and resources showing how philanthropy can lead the way in helping nonprofits during these hard economic times. Click on the links below for the articles, then share your thoughts by commenting on the SDSVP blog.

Being Nonprofit When No Profits Are Being Made
By Nancy Jamison
Local San Diego philanthropy in the economic crisis

A Giving Recession?
From Economist.com
The downturn poses new challenges for philanthropy

Philanthropy and the Economy – Part II

SDSVP is continuing to compile articles and resources showing how philanthropy can lead the way in helping nonprofits during these hard economic times. Click on the links below for the articles, then share your thoughts by commenting on the SDSVP blog.

Strategic Philanthropy in Tough Times by Paul Brest
Thoughts on how the strategic philanthropist should respond to this nearly unprecedented situation.

How to Survive a Week of Moral Hazards by Peter Karoff, Partner SVP Santa Barbara
In these unprecedented circumstances, what will be philanthropy’s response, what could it be, and how do we avoid what economists call “moral hazards”.

Bank Releases Initial Philanthropy Findings from the Boston Globe
Study shows that attitudes toward philanthropy are evolving

Philanthropy and The Economy - Part I

SDSVP has compiled several articles and resources showing how philanthropy can lead the way in helping nonprofits during these hard economic times. Click on the links below for the articles, then share your thoughts by commenting on this post.

Philanthrocapitalism on Trial
Will the collapse of the global financial system also bring down philanthrocapitalism?

In Hard Times Philanthropy Can Lead the Way
Philanthropy can help the public work through the most critical challenges facing the nation right now: making choices and setting priorities.

Managing in Tough Times: 7 Steps
Even for nonprofit leaders who are accustomed to 'making much of little,' the repercussions of the unfolding economic downturn are likely to pose unprecedented challenges.

Giving USA Spotlight - The Economy
This issue of Giving USA Spotlight looks at recessions and economic slowdowns and their impact on charitable giving in order to help nonprofit organizations anticipate what might occur in 2008–2009 and plan accordingly.

Resilient Philanthropy
While it is clear that a strong stock market provides donors with a greater ease and sense of confidence in making gifts to nonprofit organizations, the opposite is not true. Down markets do not always foretell decreased philanthropy.